A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

A silent film star on trial

Arbuckle manslaughter trials: accusations, medical evidence, and an acquittal

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · True Crime Stumper

Arbuckle manslaughter trials: accusations, medical evidence, and an acquittal

The Arbuckle manslaughter trials ended with an acquittal on April 12, 1922. Two earlier juries had failed to agree. Roscoe Arbuckle therefore left the third trial without a conviction for Virginia Rappe's death, despite the murder accusations that had filled newspapers the previous September.

Rappe became ill during a September 5, 1921, gathering at San Francisco's St. Francis Hotel. She received medical attention there before being moved to a hospital, where she died on September 9. A ruptured bladder was the central medical finding. Maude Delmont alleged that Arbuckle had assaulted Rappe; Arbuckle denied wrongdoing and described finding her ill and trying, with other guests, to help her. These were conflicting descriptions of the hotel events, rather than findings made by a jury.

The Library of Congress's newspaper guide pairs two front-page reports from September 12, 1921. It identifies a Washington Times article announcing that Arbuckle films would be barred and a Daily Ardmoreite report about first-degree murder charges. The headings document how the criminal accusation and the distribution of his films became connected in coverage published just days after Rappe's death. They also fix the reporting before any of the three trials. An announced accusation and a threatened exhibition ban were already public events, while a verdict still lay ahead.

Arbuckle surrendered and spent three weeks in jail. Police released a mug shot, and his lawyers appealed for the public to reserve judgment until the facts were established. Commercial punishment was already under way. Smithsonian identifies Crazy to Marry as a film pulled from theaters during the first wave of outrage. It describes Paramount's earlier agreement to pay Arbuckle $3 million over three years for 18 silent films. Arbuckle's films had previously enjoyed extensive promotion: the Library of Congress dates his especially successful newspaper publicity to 1917–1921. Exhibitors were now withdrawing the very performances that had made him familiar to audiences, before any jury had returned a verdict.

The first jury divided 10–2 in favor of acquittal, according to Smithsonian's later history, and the second also deadlocked. Neither proceeding produced a conviction or a unanimous acquittal. Arbuckle had testified in his own defense at the first trial. Buster Keaton and Charlie Chaplin publicly vouched for his character while the prosecution continued. Delmont, whose allegations had helped launch the prosecution, was never called to testify. Smithsonian describes prosecutors' concerns about her reliability.

Medical testimony was central to the Arbuckle manslaughter trials, and Smithsonian describes the defense's use of evidence about a chronic bladder condition. The autopsy, as quoted there, recorded no external signs of an assault. At first, Arbuckle refused to let his lawyers call witnesses with damaging accounts of Rappe's past, saying he wanted to respect the dead. By the third trial, he allowed those witnesses to testify. They described earlier abdominal attacks and her conduct after drinking. Smithsonian reports that his defense cost more than $700,000, draining the earnings from his screen career. A doctor who treated Rappe at the hotel testified that she had said Arbuckle had not tried to assault her sexually. The prosecution had that account excluded as hearsay. A finding of rupture thus did not, by itself, settle the dispute over how the fatal injury occurred.

At the end of the third of the Arbuckle manslaughter trials, the jury returned an acquittal. Smithsonian dates the verdict to April 12, 1922 and describes five minutes of deliberation. Its account says four of those minutes were used to prepare the jurors' statement. The jurors also issued a statement saying they believed Arbuckle's testimony and considered him free of blame.

The industry response did not follow the verdict automatically. The Library of Congress's film-preservation history places the scandal alongside the February 1922 murder of director William Desmond Taylor. The two cases intensified pressure from censorship boards and the threat of congressional investigation. Studios recruited Will Hays, then postmaster general and a former Republican Party chairman, to lead the newly formed Motion Picture Producers and Distributors Association. His assignment was to reduce the prospect of outside regulation. This gave the film business an official whose authority concerned its public standing, separate from the jury's decision in a criminal case. Hays's later rules included the 1924 Formula, the 1927 Don’ts and Be Carefuls, and the 1930 production code. These measures place the response to Arbuckle within a broader effort to regulate films and protect the industry from government intervention.

After the trials, a return to work remained uncertain. The screen ban arrived one week after the acquittal, according to Smithsonian's account. Smithsonian traces a longer aftermath: Hays reversed the restriction eight months later, and Arbuckle directed under the name William B. Goodrich.

The Question

Was the silent film star accused over Virginia Rappe's death ultimately convicted?

Show the answer

The Answer

No. Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle was acquitted of manslaughter by the third jury. Two earlier trials had ended with deadlocked juries.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.