A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

The wartime courtroom behind eight convictions

The 1942 saboteur trial and the Supreme Court’s summer sitting

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

The 1942 saboteur trial and the Supreme Court’s summer sitting

The 1942 saboteur trial took place before a military commission composed of seven U.S. Army officers. Its eight defendants were German-born men who had arrived in the United States on a wartime mission and were arrested before carrying out sabotage. The prosecution proceeded in the Department of Justice Building in Washington, D.C. A challenge to the commission's authority reached the Supreme Court while the military proceeding was still under way.

The FBI's case history records two landings in June 1942, one on Long Island and the other in Florida. George John Dasch, a member of the first group, contacted the bureau in New York on June 14 and again from Washington on June 19. He was taken into custody and disclosed the other men's identities. Arrests in New York and Chicago followed, and all eight were in custody by June 27. His cooperation became part of the case against the group and later figured in the reduction of his sentence.

The choice of a military forum followed discussions among senior officials. A National Archives history based on Army records describes a June 28 memorandum from Judge Advocate General Myron C. Cramer to Secretary of War Henry Stimson. Cramer considered the penalties likely in civilian court inadequate and anticipated difficulty obtaining a sabotage conviction under federal evidentiary rules. Stimson and Attorney General Francis Biddle agreed the following day that a military commission was preferable. Their recommendation preceded the presidential order establishing the commission on July 2.

Four major generals and three brigadier generals formed the panel. Biddle and Cramer served as co-prosecutors, while military counsel represented the defendants. Colonel Kenneth C. Royall was among the defense lawyers. Proceedings began on July 8, and the Archives history records 16 days devoted to preliminary arguments and testimony. The FBI's historical photograph places the commission in a fifth-floor courtroom at the Justice Department. A desk used in the proceedings, preserved in the bureau's artifact collection, had been located in that building during the trial and was subsequently retained at FBI headquarters.

The charges in the 1942 saboteur trial included violation of the law of war, offenses under Articles 81 and 82 of the Articles of War, and conspiracy to commit the alleged offenses. The Supreme Court's opinion records that the Army lodged them on July 3. By July 27, the prosecution and defense had presented their evidence, with counsel's arguments still to come. Seven defendants challenged their detention and the commission's jurisdiction. They contended that the Constitution entitled them to proceedings in civilian courts, which remained open and functioning throughout the case.

The Supreme Court convened a special term and heard arguments on July 29 and 30. On July 31, it upheld the commission's lawful constitution and the petitioners' custody for trial, denying the requested discharge. The short decision preceded the full opinion explaining the result. The justices expressly distinguished the jurisdictional dispute from a determination of guilt or innocence. The criminal findings belonged to the military commission, whose authority had been the subject of the petitions before the Court.

All eight defendants were found guilty and sentenced to death. The sentences of Dasch and Ernest Peter Burger were commuted after appeals for clemency. Dasch received 30 years in prison and Burger life imprisonment; the other six men were executed on August 8, 1942. The FBI's history records a further executive decision in April 1948, when clemency for Dasch and Burger was conditioned on deportation. They were transported to the American occupation zone in Germany, and the unserved portions of their sentences were suspended subject to conditions imposed there.

The 1942 saboteur trial continued to occupy the justices after the July ruling. The Federal Judicial Center's history describes disagreements over the legal reasoning and the relationship between the executive order, congressional legislation, and judicial review. Justice Owen Roberts opposed denying federal-court review, while Justice Robert Jackson circulated a memorandum favoring restraint in reviewing military judgments. These internal disagreements occurred despite the Court's earlier announcement that the commission could proceed.

Justice Felix Frankfurter circulated an imaginary dialogue titled F.F.'s Soliloquy in an effort to bring his colleagues together. Frankfurter appealed to wartime unity and criticized the prospect of an institutional conflict among the branches of government. The dialogue was an internal intervention rather than a conversation that occurred with a defendant. Chief Justice Harlan Fiske Stone's full opinion was filed on October 29, 1942, nearly three months after the initial order and after the six executions. It upheld the military commission's jurisdiction in the case.

The Question

What kind of tribunal tried the eight German saboteurs in Washington, D.C., in 1942?

Show the answer

The Answer

A military commission of seven U.S. Army officers. The Supreme Court upheld its authority to conduct the trial in Ex parte Quirin.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.