A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

What linked the stolen maps to their original books?

Smiley map thefts: the old paper evidence behind the recoveries

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Smiley map thefts: the old paper evidence behind the recoveries

The Smiley map thefts came to light at Yale's Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library in June 2005. A library employee found a knife blade on the floor of the rare documents room and checked the library register. The visitor she identified was Edward Forbes Smiley III. She found his name online, learned that he dealt in rare maps, and alerted security. Police subsequently found him carrying seven maps, including a nearly 500-year-old item worth more than $150,000.

Edward Forbes Smiley III was an established rare-map dealer who had access to major research collections. Harvard Magazine reported that he had studied church history and classics at Hampshire College and spent a year at Princeton Theological Seminary before entering the map business. After his June 2005 arrest at Yale's Beinecke Library, Harvard conducted an extensive assessment of its map holdings and reported 13 missing maps to investigators.

The Smiley map thefts became a federal investigation after Yale officials suspected losses beyond their own library and possible sales overseas. The FBI described cooperation among its New Haven office, Boston police, university police at Yale and Harvard, the New York Public Library's security division, and Scotland Yard. Investigators worked with map specialists, dealers, and collectors. Smiley's admissions helped locate purchasers, but tracing a transaction and establishing the original institutional owner remained separate parts of the recovery work.

On June 22, 2006, Smiley admitted in federal court that he had stolen 97 maps valued at more than $3 million. He pleaded guilty to one count of theft of major artwork in federal court and three larceny counts in state court. His admitted thefts included eight maps from Houghton's collection. Among those was a 1524 New World map associated with Hernan Cortes. Harvard's initial inventory had identified five additional missing maps that were outside the eight thefts he acknowledged there.

The physical identifications were complicated by titles as well as ownership. Some maps bore different titles, including Latin ones, and copies could have originated in several examples of the same printed book. The FBI's September 2006 report said worm damage in certain volumes supplied distinctive matching evidence. It described 86 maps as recovered at that point. Those recoveries required institutional knowledge of individual books and sheets; an admission that a map had been stolen did not by itself identify which surviving copy investigators had found.

Contemporary statements from Harvard distinguished financial loss from the effect on the collections. In June 2006, the library said an intact rare book had a value different from a volume missing its original material. Its representatives also described a loss to scholarship when historical material became unavailable. The Justice Department's public-information officer told The Harvard Crimson that dealers who purchased the stolen maps often bore much of the financial loss. The affected parties therefore included institutions deprived of material and purchasers who had paid Smiley for it.

Smiley's cooperation broadened the thefts that the government could establish. Harvard Magazine reported before sentencing that, without his admissions, prosecutors could establish his guilt in only 18 thefts. Its September 2006 coverage put his possible federal term at 57 to 71 months and reported his agreement to serve a concurrent five-year state sentence. Smiley also said he would create a restitution fund, including sale of his half interest in a Vineyard home and property in Maine.

Sentencing brought those different interests into court. On September 27, 2006, federal Judge Janet Bond Arterton sentenced Smiley to 42 months in prison, followed by three years of supervised release, and ordered nearly $2 million in restitution. Harvard had submitted a victim-impact statement seeking the maximum punishment. Federal prosecutors supported a lighter sentence in recognition of Smiley's substantial cooperation. The U.S. Attorney described the imposed sentence as balancing the seriousness of the crime against assistance that had recovered most of the stolen maps. State sentencing on the Yale larceny charges remained scheduled for October.

In July 2013, the FBI was still working on recoveries from the Smiley map thefts. In its annual publication, the FBI reported possession of 28 rare maps and books whose owners had not been established. Some dated to the 17th century. The retained objects included an 18th-century depiction of the United States and a 1683 street plan of Philadelphia. The bureau stated that the material had been legally forfeited to the U.S. government and published images in a renewed effort to locate its owners. Most stolen material had been returned, but these particular objects remained in federal custody in July 2013.

The Question

What physical feature helped investigators identify some maps recovered in the Smiley theft case?

Show the answer

The Answer

Matching wormholes helped identify some recovered maps. The FBI reported that damage extending through the original books supplied distinctive evidence linking the sheets to their collections.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.