The Hiss perjury case and the two statements before a grand jury
The Hiss perjury case produced a guilty verdict on January 21, 1950, after two trials of a former State Department official. Alger Hiss was convicted on two counts of lying under oath before a federal grand jury. Espionage allegations had driven the investigation, but the convictions were for perjury. The FBI's historical account states that an espionage prosecution was barred by the time limit applicable to those earlier acts.
The accusation came from Whittaker Chambers, a former member of the Communist underground who had become a senior editor at Time. In August 1948, he appeared before the House Committee on Un-American Activities and named Hiss as a former associate in the underground. Hiss denied Communist membership and disputed Chambers's account. He later acknowledged knowing a man whom he had called George Crosley and identified that man as Chambers. He also brought a libel action against his accuser, creating a separate civil proceeding alongside the congressional investigation.
The federal indictment concerned testimony given on December 15, 1948. As the Second Circuit subsequently described it, Hiss had denied that he or his wife, in his presence, had transferred government documents or copies to Chambers or another unauthorized person. He had also testified that he believed he could state definitely that he had not seen Chambers after January 1, 1937. The indictment assigned a count to each statement. The criminal allegations therefore concerned two particular sworn denials, with the earlier relationship and the documents becoming evidence about their truthfulness.
Documents emerged during pretrial proceedings in the libel action. The appellate opinion recorded that Chambers produced 43 typewritten documents and four penciled memoranda in November 1948. The memoranda were acknowledged to be in Hiss's handwriting. All but one of the typed documents were associated with a Woodstock typewriter formerly belonging to the Hiss household. In December, Chambers also produced microfilm that had been concealed on his Maryland farm. The FBI's later history identifies the documentary revelations collectively with the familiar name Pumpkin Papers.
The Hiss perjury case included competing testimony about the typewriter's whereabouts. In the trial excerpts preserved by the Famous Trials collection, Priscilla Hiss said she had received the machine from her father in 1932. She acknowledged typing comparison documents on it during the 1930s. She denied giving Chambers the disputed government papers or agreeing to copy State Department documents for him. She testified that the typewriter had left the household in December 1937, before the dates on the documents central to the prosecution. Those statements were defense testimony rather than findings accepted by the jury.
Esther Chambers supplied a different account of the families' relationship. Her trial testimony recalled meeting Alger Hiss in 1934 and seeing him on numerous later occasions. She described gifts from Priscilla and a celebration of the Hisses' wedding anniversary in December 1937. Her husband was therefore not the only witness describing contact after the date in Hiss's grand jury denial. The transcript excerpts also preserve disputes during cross-examination about the precision of her recollections of dates.
The National Archives' description of the criminal file dates the first trial from May 31 to July 8, 1949. Its jury could not agree. A second jury returned guilty verdicts on both counts in January 1950, and Hiss received a five-year prison sentence. The record of the first proceeding included character testimony from Illinois Governor Adlai Stevenson, who had worked with Hiss at the State Department. The two trials consequently preserved evidence about professional reputation alongside the disputed documents and accounts of personal acquaintance.
On December 7, 1950, the Second Circuit affirmed the judgment. Its opinion examined whether evidence independent of Whittaker Chambers sufficiently supported his testimony under the rules governing perjury prosecutions. The court held that the documentary circumstances and other testimony met the required standard. It also concluded that the jury could find that the Woodstock remained in the Hiss home when the disputed copies were made. This was the appellate court's assessment of the trial record, following the jury's verdict.
The surviving Hiss perjury case records extended beyond the courtroom transcripts. In 1999, the National Archives announced the opening of seven volumes of formerly secret grand jury testimony, approximately 4,000 pages covering proceedings from July 1947 through May 1949. District court orders dated May 13 and July 14, 1999, governed the release, with some material withheld for privacy or because it fell outside the request. The announced witnesses included Hiss, Chambers, Harry Dexter White, and Congressman Karl E. Mundt. A separate grand jury had continued related espionage inquiries until 1950. In its 2018 description, the Archives identified the criminal case file as 149 documents totaling 9,309 pages, including the indictment and stenographic minutes.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, United States v. Hiss, 185 F.2d 822, December 7, 1950 — openjurist.org
- FBI, Alger Hiss: the investigation and perjury convictions — www.fbi.gov
- National Archives, United States of America v. Alger Hiss: criminal case records, July 26, 2018 — www.archives.gov
- National Archives to Make Available Alger Hiss Grand Jury Materials, July 14, 1999 — www.archives.gov
- Famous Trials, The Alger Hiss Trials: Excerpts from the Trial Transcripts, Priscilla Hiss and Esther Chambers testimony — www.famous-trials.com