DNA fingerprinting and the route to Colin Pitchfork
DNA fingerprinting helped connect Colin Pitchfork with two murders before his conviction in 1988. The investigation also cleared an earlier suspect, making the case an early example of biological comparisons changing the direction of a murder inquiry. The scientific method had developed from research into inherited variation. Its use in police work depended on separate steps: recognizing patterns that differed between people, obtaining interpretable patterns from crime-scene material, and comparing those traces with a correctly identified reference sample.
Guinness World Records describes the initial suspect as Richard Buckland, who confessed to the second of the two killings investigated in Leicestershire. His DNA did not match the killer's. The tests therefore excluded a person already under suspicion rather than simply confirming the confession. The inquiry then became a mass sampling effort involving 5,000 local men. Pitchfork tried to evade it by arranging for another man's sample to be submitted in his place. Once that substitution was discovered, his own sample matched the crime evidence, and he received life imprisonment in 1988.
The two victims were Lynda Mann and Dawn Ashworth. The case is remembered for its DNA fingerprinting conviction, but the earlier exclusion explains another essential property of the method. A confession and a laboratory comparison are different kinds of evidence, and the latter can conflict with the former. Likewise, a sample attributed to a person does not necessarily come from that person. The impersonation interfered with the reference-sampling process. Obtaining Pitchfork's own material restored the connection between the laboratory pattern and the individual whose identity the investigation needed to assess.
Jeffreys explained the laboratory origins in a 2009 PLOS Genetics interview with Jane Gitschier. Work on the human myoglobin gene had identified a minisatellite within an intron. Comparing that repeat with other sequences suggested a shared core. The researchers used it to isolate additional repetitive regions, some highly variable between people. This was an attempt to obtain informative genetic markers, with medical genetics driving the investigation. Crime detection was an application recognized after the identifying pattern appeared, rather than the experimental project's starting instruction.
The decisive DNA fingerprinting experiment used a Southern blot that happened to contain material from a laboratory technician and her parents. Jeffreys recalled a fuzzy pattern resembling a barcode, with differences between the individuals and an apparent pattern of inheritance within the family. The important observation combined individuality and relationship: the samples were distinguishable, yet their patterns also carried family information. A repeated core sequence could reveal variation at several places in the genome at once. That gave the result possibilities beyond following a single inherited marker.
Jeffreys returned to the experimental sequence in a 2013 interview published in Investigative Genetics. He dated the key experiment to September 1984 and described a probe made from repeated copies of the shared sequence. It detected several minisatellites simultaneously. The resulting pattern suggested uses in personal identification and family relationships almost immediately. The first experiment also included nonhuman species, which opened possibilities for studying wild populations. The method's potential therefore extended beyond matching a suspect with a trace left at a crime scene.
The practical forensic question remained open at that first moment. Jeffreys recalled leaving blood spots around the laboratory as a mock crime scene because the researchers did not yet know whether DNA survived in such material or could be analyzed. His wife, Sue, suggested another application that evening: immigration disputes involving uncertain family relationships. He identified an immigration dispute as the first casework undertaken with DNA fingerprinting. The route from discovery to murder investigation thus included experiments on material survival and an earlier application to kinship.
The 2013 interview also describes the original laboratory process: cutting DNA with a restriction enzyme, separating it in a gel, making a Southern blot and applying a radioactive or chemiluminescent probe. It required substantial quantities of DNA and could take a week or two to return a result. Jeffreys identified limited sensitivity and slow processing as reasons to seek a faster method suitable for automation. Those limitations belonged to the technique used before the later adoption of shorter repeat markers and amplification methods.
Later techniques use shorter repeat markers. The National Human Genome Research Institute explains how short tandem repeats can gain or lose copies between generations, creating variation across the population. Its example uses repeated GAAT units at the TPOX gene. A difference in repeat count can distinguish samples without necessarily changing the gene's function. This later explanation helps separate inherited sequence variation from an ordinary visible trait. Across the early experiments and the murder inquiry, the crucial relationship was a comparison between patterns, together with reliable identification of the material being compared.
- Guinness World Records, First use of DNA profiling to clear a criminal suspect: Buckland, sampling and Pitchfork — www.guinnessworldrecords.com
- Jane Gitschier, The Eureka Moment: An Interview with Sir Alec Jeffreys, PLOS Genetics, 2009 — journals.plos.org
- Alec J. Jeffreys, The man behind the DNA fingerprints: an interview with Professor Sir Alec Jeffreys, Investigative Genetics, 2013, PubMed Central full text — pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- National Human Genome Research Institute, Enhanced Forensics: inherited variation and short tandem repeats — www.genome.gov
- BBC News, Can we still rely on DNA sampling to crack crime?, 5 May 2015: first conviction and victims’ names — www.bbc.com