A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

DNA testing in the Bobby Dunbar case

Bobby Dunbar DNA: a family link fails after a lifetime under one name

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Bobby Dunbar DNA: a family link fails after a lifetime under one name

The Bobby Dunbar DNA comparison reported in 2004 did not match the two family lines it was meant to connect. Robert Dunbar Jr., whose father had grown up as Bobby, supplied one sample; a son of Alonzo, the missing child's brother, supplied the other. Associated Press reporter Allen G. Breed reported that mismatch after speaking with Robert. The result challenged the recovered boy's identity, but it did not locate the child who had disappeared in 1912.

The uncertainty had survived inside a family archive. In This American Life, Margaret Dunbar Cutright recalled receiving her great-grandmother's scrapbook from her father in 1999. It held roughly 400 articles, along with photographs and letters. She found incompatible newspaper descriptions of the reunion: immediate recognition in one account, hesitation in another. Her research began with material the family had preserved as part of its own history. Reading those reports together made their disagreements visible. The scrapbook supplied competing accounts of an identification, rather than a biological record of the recovered boy.

The dispute originally involved another mother and a traveling worker. Jake Rossen's account in Mental Floss describes William Cantwell Walters insisting that his companion was Bruce Anderson, Julia Anderson's son from North Carolina. A newspaper paid for Julia to travel south in 1913. She was asked to identify her child among several boys, and her initial uncertainty became part of the public argument against Walters. The circumstances required adults to interpret appearance and recognition after a long separation. Julia's claim and the Dunbars' claim attached different histories to the same child.

Walters was convicted in Opelousas and sentenced to life imprisonment. Rossen reports that his lawyer successfully challenged the kidnapping law over an omission in its text, and the prosecution did not try him again. That legal outcome addressed the authority for the conviction. It did not supply a genetic comparison between the boy and either family. The distinction matters because release from a sentence, acceptance into a household, and biological kinship answer different questions. The child continued growing up under the Dunbar name despite the end of the criminal prosecution against Walters.

The later Bobby Dunbar DNA comparison depended on relatives willing to take part. In the radio program, Robert and Margaret described choosing a test, with Alonzo's son David agreeing to supply the comparison sample. Margaret recalled a laboratory assistant giving her the mismatch over the telephone, followed by her journey to tell her hospitalized father. Their interviews identify the participants and describe receiving the news. They do not reproduce a laboratory report listing the markers, their numerical values, or the calculations used to interpret them. The public account and the underlying laboratory record remain different documents.

The choice of relatives followed a particular route through inheritance. The National Institute of Standards and Technology explains that Y-chromosome DNA passes from father to son. Testing a male descendant from each paternal line can therefore investigate whether those lines share a male ancestor. Laboratories examine short tandem repeats, stretches of DNA in which a sequence repeats a certain number of times. The repeat count at each selected location becomes a marker for comparison. This is more specific than asking whether two people have the same surname, and narrower than comparing every branch in a family tree.

Consistent measurement is essential to that process. NIST's 2008 account describes how counting repeats differently can produce missed connections or misleading matches between laboratories. It recommends a certified reference material, SRM 2395, to help align their measurements. A reference sample provides a common basis for checking equipment and reporting results. That general explanation describes laboratory quality control; it is not a second test of the Dunbar samples. Nothing in the NIST account establishes which reference materials the laboratory in this particular case used or how many markers it compared.

The associated research paper makes the reporting problem concrete. John M. Butler, Margaret C. Kline and Amy E. Decker described 120 different Y-chromosome repeat markers in use among genetic genealogy laboratories in 2008. They explained that two laboratories could assign different names to the same genetic variant, requiring conversion before results could be compared. Their paper called for shared reference materials, consistent naming and common choices of locations to examine. Such standards help make results comparable across services. They also explain why a bare statement that samples matched or differed contains less information than the complete laboratory documentation.

The Bobby Dunbar DNA result changed an inherited identification without reconstructing every earlier event. A family scrapbook, a criminal conviction, an appeal and a paternal-line comparison carry different kinds of information. Keeping their limits visible leaves room to acknowledge the exclusion while recognizing how much of the missing child's story remains unanswered.

The Question

What did DNA testing reveal about the boy who grew up as Bobby Dunbar?

Show the answer

The Answer

He was not biologically related to the Dunbar family. In 2004, testing showed that his son was not related by blood to the son of Alonzo Dunbar, the missing child's brother.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.