A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

Sherri Papini's disappearance and the missing weeks

Sherri Papini: the 22 missing days and the DNA that explained them

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Sherri Papini: the 22 missing days and the DNA that explained them

During the 22 days Sherri Papini was missing in 2016, she was staying with a former boyfriend in Southern California. DNA found on her clothing led investigators to him, and he told FBI agents that he had helped her run away. The kidnapping story that held the country's attention for years ended with a guilty plea to lying to federal agents and to mail fraud.

On November 2, 2016, Keith Papini came home from work to an empty house in Mountain Gate, California. His two children had not been picked up from day care. The location feature on his wife's phone showed it near Sunrise Drive, where she had gone for a run. He found the phone and earbuds in the dirt about two feet off the road. The phone was playing the couple's wedding song, Michael Buble's "Everything," on repeat. An FBI affidavit says he thought the phone had been placed there, which he described as weird.

Sherri Papini, then 34, reappeared on Thanksgiving Day. California Highway Patrol officers answered multiple 911 calls about a woman wandering onto Interstate 5 near Woodland, 146 miles south of her home. She told investigators that she had been jogging when a dark-colored SUV carrying two women stopped, that one woman beckoned her over and then pulled a gun, and that she left her phone behind as evidence before getting into the vehicle. She said she slept most of the drive, woke in a room and was held until the younger woman drove her back to the highway. The FBI released sketches of the two women. Agents later said those women never existed.

The disappearance drew international headlines and rallies. A GoFundMe account for the family raised $49,070, and the affidavit alleges it went toward credit card bills and personal expenses. The California Victim Compensation Board paid her more than $30,000 for blinds for her home, an ambulance ride and therapy sessions. That money became the basis of the mail fraud charge.

The case turned on DNA. While she recovered in the hospital, Shasta County Sheriff's deputies sent her clothing to a lab. The profile of an unknown male found on the clothing was uploaded to the national DNA index and routinely searched against other profiles. On September 26, 2019, detectives asked the California Department of Justice for a familial search, which looks for near-matches likely to come from relatives. On March 19, 2020, the state's Familial Search Committee voted to release a result, and the lab was told that a man identified as Person 2 was a potential relative of the unknown contributor. According to the FBI affidavit, Person 2 had two living sons, one of them the ex-boyfriend. On June 9, 2020, the FBI visited his home and collected items from his garbage, including a green tea bottle. Analysis found DNA on it matching the DNA from her clothing.

On August 10, 2020, he agreed to an interview. According to the affidavit, he admitted immediately that he had helped Papini run away. He had known her since they were teenagers, he said, and she contacted him out of the blue and claimed that her husband was abusing her and she was trying to escape. No police reports alleging such abuse were ever filed. He told agents that on November 2, 2016, he drove from his residence in Southern California to Redding to pick her up after her morning run, and that she slept most of the drive south in the back seat of his car. She stayed at his apartment in Costa Mesa, nearly 600 miles from Redding, for the weeks that followed. The two used prepaid phones to communicate, and cell phone records from both people corroborated his account, according to the affidavit. After 22 days, he said, she told him she missed her children, and he dropped her off where she told him to.

Agents then returned to question Sherri Papini herself. They told her repeatedly that lying to federal agents is a crime. According to the FBI, she repeated her story of being abducted by two women and denied meeting her ex-boyfriend. The U.S. Attorney's Office said she was presented with evidence that she had not been abducted and, instead of retracting the story, continued to make false statements about her purported abductors.

FBI agents arrested Sherri Papini on March 3, 2022. She was charged with lying to a federal agent and with mail fraud. The mail fraud count carried up to 20 years and the false statement count up to five. Her family denied the allegations at first. She spent five nights in the Sacramento County Main Jail before a judge released her on a $120,000 bond.

About six weeks after the arrest, she signed a plea agreement. Her attorney, William Portanova, said it would take the case in an entirely new direction. In a statement, Papini said, "I am deeply ashamed of myself for my behavior," and added, "I will work the rest of my life to make amends for what I have done." She pleaded guilty to making false statements and mail fraud. Two days later her husband filed for divorce.

In September 2022 Sherri Papini was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison. In 2023 prison records showed Papini, then 41, living at a residential reentry facility in Sacramento County under community confinement, with release from that confinement scheduled for late October.

The Question

Where did Sherri Papini stay during the weeks she was missing in 2016?

Show the answer

The Answer

At a former boyfriend's home in Southern California. DNA on her clothing, traced through a familial DNA search to a relative of his, led investigators to him, and he told FBI agents he had helped her run away.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.