A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

What did DNA testing reveal about Jesse James?

Jesse James: the 1995 DNA test at Kearney

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Jesse James: the 1995 DNA test at Kearney

In 1995 researchers opened a grave at Mt. Olivet Cemetery in Kearney, Missouri, to test whether Jesse James died on April 3, 1882, or faked his death and lived under other names. The team was led by Dr. James E. Starrs, a forensic science professor and lawyer at George Washington University. He said, "There's a certain historic mystery that needs to be verified," and added, "DNA can solve these mysteries." The testing pointed to the same answer the historical record gave: the remains were almost certainly Jesse James's.

The record of his death is specific. Jesse James was shot in the back of the head while dusting a picture on the wall of his rented home in St. Joseph, Missouri. His wife and two children were in a nearby room. Bob Ford, a recent recruit to the James gang, fired the shot, having conspired with his older brother Charley, who was already in the gang. Earlier that year Bob Ford had arranged with Missouri's governor to kill James in exchange for a reward. After the Fords told authorities what they had done, they were convicted of murder and sentenced to hang, and the governor quickly pardoned them. They later reenacted the killing in a traveling show. James was 34. He had been born September 5, 1847, in Clay County, Missouri.

Doubt began almost at once. Speculation held that he had faked his death and that someone else lay in his grave, and over the years several men claimed to be Jesse James. Waggoner Carr, a former Texas attorney general who represents clients claiming descent from Jesse James, argued that the body was Charlie Bigelow, a James gang member who resembled him. Those clients say their family records show that Jesse James was not killed in 1882 but lived past 100 and died in Granbury, Texas, in 1951. Texas Monthly describes the Granbury group as descendants of a white-bearded man named J. Frank Dalton, whom they have long held to be the real Jesse James, and says they cite a 1951 Hood County autopsy report that identifies Dalton as Jesse Woodson James. Many people argued that Ford's account "just doesn't add up."

The burial history gave the doubters room. James was originally buried on the James family farm, and his remains were moved to Mt. Olivet Cemetery in 1902.

The 1995 plan combined several methods. Mitochondrial DNA testing was meant to identify the body, with gender and toxicology tests alongside it. Toxicology would use fingernails and toenails to look for drugs. Kansas State University and the Kansas City Regional Crime Laboratory were to handle the remains, DNA testing would take place at Penn State if a suitable bone turned up, and toxicology would go to Florida State University. George Washington University and the nonprofit Scientific Sleuthing Inc. paid for the work. The exhumation was also meant to settle what gun killed James, since Bob Ford gave conflicting accounts of a .44 or .45 caliber weapon. The team sought a court order to exhume partial remains at the James Farm too, and Starrs wanted to rebury them with the Mt. Olivet remains. The Discovery Channel filmed the project, and an estimated 300 to 500 people attended the dig in Kearney.

On the first day the team found a partially collapsed wooden coffin, bone fragments and fabric. Records said Jesse had been buried in a metal coffin, so the researchers suspected the headstones might have been reversed and that they had uncovered his wife Zerelda's coffin.

The DNA results came later, in a scientific paper. The remains were poorly preserved, and DNA came from two of four teeth. Two hairs recovered in 1978 from James's original burial site on the farm supplied a second sample. The teeth and hairs had identical mitochondrial DNA sequences in the region called HVR1, belonging to haplogroup T2 with five mutations relative to the reference sequence: 16126C, 16274A, 16294T, 16296T and 16304C. Mitochondrial DNA passes from mothers to children, so it was compared with two maternal-line descendants of James's sister Susan, a great-grandson and a great-great-grandson. Both were exact matches. The haplotype also appears in the MitoSearch database under ID EEYCU, and no exact match turned up there.

The authors were careful about the limit of that evidence. They said the mitochondrial DNA results do not by themselves establish identity, noting "the possibility (however remote)" of a different maternal relative or an unrelated person with the same sequence. They also wrote that the results agree with other scientific investigations and that "there is no scientific basis whatsoever for doubting that the exhumed remains are those of Jesse James." In their words, the burden of proof shifts to those who still doubt the identification.

Doubters pressed on. A commenter on a review of the paper listed objections about chain of custody and about the unknown origin of the hair and teeth. The comment adds that a 1978 dig retrieved remains left behind when the grave was moved in 1902. Those points come from the commenter and are not part of the paper's findings.

The Question

For decades people said a famous Missouri outlaw shot in St. Joseph in 1882 had faked his death. What did DNA testing of the remains exhumed in Kearney, Missouri, in 1995 find?

Show the answer

The Answer

Almost certainly Jesse. Mitochondrial DNA from teeth and hair matched blood samples from two maternal-line descendants of his sister Susan. The researchers wrote that there is no scientific basis for doubting the remains are his, while noting the result does not by itself establish identity.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.