A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

Who broke the silence in Boston's six-year robbery investigation?

Boston Brink's robbery: the confession after six years

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Boston Brink's robbery: the confession after six years

The Boston Brink's robbery took place on January 17, 1950, at the premises of a company that transported money and valuables. More than $1.2 million in cash and approximately $1.5 million in checks and other securities disappeared. The investigation lasted almost six years before a participant gave investigators a detailed confession. Joseph O'Keefe subsequently pleaded guilty, while eight other defendants contested the prosecution and went before a Massachusetts jury.

Boston police arrived within minutes of the robbery, and FBI agents joined the investigation. Interviews extended through the surrounding neighborhood, among employees of the building, and among people who had business with Brink's. Investigators also contacted the company's customers about the missing money and securities. The early physical evidence included a chauffeur's cap, which became part of the FBI's historical artifact collection. Brink's offered $100,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of those responsible.

The Boston Brink's robbery reached a federal grand jury in November 1952. According to the FBI's description of the surviving cap, the jurors considered the evidence insufficient to identify the robbers. Suspicion had focused on several criminal groups, but the inquiry ended without the result investigators sought. In January 1956, a Suffolk County grand jury charged 11 men in the Massachusetts proceeding. According to the FBI's artifact history, 10 of them had appeared before the earlier federal grand jury.

O'Keefe spoke to the FBI in January 1956 while imprisoned for violating probation in another case. The bureau attributed his decision to growing bitterness toward his associates. They were spending stolen money while rejecting his demands for help with legal expenses. He described the robbery in a series of interviews, and agents checked his statements after each session. His cooperation supplied the detailed participation evidence that the earlier grand jury had lacked. He later became a prosecution witness against the other men.

A separate development brought stolen currency back into official custody in June 1956. An amusement-arcade operator in Baltimore reported a $10 bill he suspected was counterfeit. A Secret Service examination established that the money was genuine, and the FBI identified some recovered bills as proceeds of the Boston robbery. The investigation extended to offices on Tremont Street in Boston, where more currency was recovered. The bureau identified $51,906 there as stolen Brink's money. Even after these recoveries, more than $1,150,000 in currency remained unaccounted for. Of $4,822 recovered from the man in Baltimore, the FBI identified $4,635 as stolen Brink's currency.

The Boston FBI, Massachusetts State Police, and Boston Police had shared the long investigation. Eight defendants went to trial in August 1956: Anthony Pino, Joseph McGinnis, Vincent Costa, Henry Baker, Adolph Maffie, Michael Geagan, James Faherty, and Thomas Richardson. O'Keefe's guilty plea placed him in a different position from those defendants. Stanley Gusciora and Joseph Banfield had died before trial. The eight men who were tried were found guilty on October 6, 1956, and sentenced on October 9. Each received a life sentence, although their precise offenses and additional sentences differed. McGinnis's life sentences were for being an accessory before the fact; seven others received life sentences for robbery.

The convictions generated further litigation over the publicity surrounding the Boston Brink's robbery. The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court affirmed the judgments in 1959. The prisoners then sought federal habeas corpus relief, arguing that sustained publicity, including information issued by law-enforcement officials, had deprived them of a fair trial under the Fourteenth Amendment. A federal district court denied their petition. Their appeal reached the First Circuit, which examined whether the selected jurors had been impartial despite the widespread coverage.

The First Circuit's decision of June 30, 1961, described the trial as orderly. The trial judge had conducted the individual juror examinations, and the first juror had not been seated until the thirteenth day of selection. One challenged juror described his opinion as not firm; the other said he had a tentative view that could change. Both said they could follow the court's instructions and decide the case from the evidence. Defense counsel had not requested a change of venue or a postponement, but the First Circuit considered their publicity objection on its merits. After independently evaluating the selected jurors' examinations, the appellate judges rejected the challenge and affirmed the district court's judgment.

On May 28, 1962, the U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari in Geagan et al. v. Gavin. Its published order identified the First Circuit decision at 292 F.2d 244 as the judgment below. That order left the federal appellate result in place, following the earlier Massachusetts affirmance and the unsuccessful habeas corpus petition.

The Question

Which participant's confession helped solve the 1950 Boston Brink's robbery?

Show the answer

The Answer

Joseph O'Keefe confessed to the FBI in January 1956. He later pleaded guilty and testified against the eight defendants tried for offenses arising from the robbery.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.