The Weyerhaeuser kidnapping: a store counter and the court record
The Weyerhaeuser kidnapping began in Tacoma on May 24, 1935, when 9-year-old George Weyerhaeuser disappeared while walking home from school. His family paid $200,000, and he returned safely on June 1. A week later, a cashier in a Salt Lake City Woolworth store recognized a bill from the ransom. The transaction brought Margaret Waley into police custody and became a decisive episode in the investigation detailed by HistoryLink.
Federal responsibility in Washington then rested with an office outside the state. The FBI's Seattle history records that its Seattle office closed in 1932 and its territory passed to Portland. The Weyerhaeuser investigation unfolded during that arrangement. Seattle did not regain its own field division until 1937, when Ray C. Suran was directed to establish it in the Vance Building. The bureau's regional organization therefore explains Portland's appearance in an investigation centered on a Tacoma family and a Washington disappearance.
HistoryLink's chronology places George's disappearance in an ordinary disruption of the school day. Lowell Elementary had dismissed its pupils early, and George reached Annie Wright Seminary before his sister Anne was ready. Their chauffeur normally collected both children there for lunch. George began walking toward home instead. That evening, a special-delivery ransom demand reached the family. His father, John Philip Weyerhaeuser Jr., then faced days of negotiations while federal agents investigated the disappearance.
The family's communications appeared in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, attracting attention well beyond Tacoma. HistoryLink records that authorities agreed to refrain from interfering with the negotiations until George's release. The family subsequently stopped giving the press further information about those negotiations. After the payment, George was released near Issaquah in the early hours of June 1. He reached a farm belonging to Louis and Willena Bonifas, who helped begin his return to Tacoma. The child's release preceded the principal arrests; the investigation continued after he was home.
The Weyerhaeuser kidnapping also became a contest among newspapers for exclusive information. A separate HistoryLink chronology describes Seattle Times sportswriter John H. Dreher intercepting the car carrying George home and obtaining an interview during the journey. The newspaper published his account in extra editions, and The Associated Press distributed it nationally. At the Weyerhaeuser residence, family spokesman Henry Marfield Bolcom announced that George had returned safely and requested restraint in publishing further details. The interview and the family's request belonged to the same morning, as public attention converged on the returned child.
HistoryLink's case history records an earlier appearance of ransom currency on June 2, 1935, in a railway-ticket purchase from Huntington, Oregon, to Salt Lake City. More bills subsequently appeared in Salt Lake City's stores. HistoryLink identifies the officers at Woolworth as Detective William M. Rogers and Patrolman L. B. Gifford. Police detectives had been stationed in Salt Lake City's downtown discount stores after ransom currency began circulating there. On June 8, a Woolworth cashier notified a detective about a bill presented by Margaret Waley. Another ransom bill was found in her pocketbook at the field office. Harmon Metz Waley was arrested at their residence later that day. Investigators also recovered partially burned currency, which the FBI Laboratory identified as part of the ransom.
The defendants in the Weyerhaeuser kidnapping followed different paths through court. Harmon pleaded guilty in June 1935 and received concurrent terms of 45 years for kidnapping and two years for conspiracy. Margaret contested the charges. HistoryLink's longer history describes more than 40 prosecution witnesses and her testimony that she had learned of the abduction after it occurred. A jury found her guilty, and she received concurrent 20-year terms. William Dainard remained at large until May 1936, then pleaded guilty and received concurrent 60-year terms. Edward Fliss later pleaded guilty to assisting with the disposition of ransom money and received a 10-year sentence.
Harmon's plea subsequently produced a separate constitutional proceeding. In Waley v. Johnston, decided April 27, 1942, the Supreme Court considered his sworn allegation that an FBI agent had coerced the plea through threats involving false evidence and publicity. A district court had rejected his habeas corpus petition without hearing evidence, and the Ninth Circuit had affirmed. The government's response included an agent's statement that Waley had confessed voluntarily, but it did not specifically deny the particular allegations on which his petition relied.
The government acknowledged error before the Supreme Court. The justices held that those specific, unanswered allegations required a hearing, while observing that they might strain belief. They vacated the judgment rejecting the petition and remanded the proceeding. Their ruling did not establish that the alleged threats had occurred or declare Waley innocent. It required a factual hearing on the claimed coercion, adding a distinct judicial record to the arrests, pleas, and verdicts arising from the Weyerhaeuser kidnapping.
- Daryl C. McClary, Weyerhaeuser Kidnapping, HistoryLink Essay 7711 — historylink.org
- FBI Seattle History: the 1932 closure, Portland jurisdiction, and 1937 reopening — www.fbi.gov
- Daryl C. McClary, George H. Weyerhaeuser is kidnapped in Tacoma and held for ransom on May 24, 1935, HistoryLink Essay 7724 — www.historylink.org
- U.S. Supreme Court, Waley v. Johnston, 316 U.S. 101, April 27, 1942 — www.law.cornell.edu