Zodiac 340 cipher: a decoded message without an identified killer
The Zodiac 340 cipher yielded a message in December 2020, after remaining unsolved for 51 years. It did not yield the killer's name. David Oranchak, Sam Blake, and Jarl Van Eycke recovered a taunt about pursuit, television, execution, and an imagined afterlife. The technical achievement concerned the transformation of symbols into language. The speaker's identity remained a separate investigative problem, and the statements about death and paradise remained that speaker's assertions.
The earlier correspondence had already encouraged expectations that a cipher might identify its sender. In July 1969, a 408-character cryptogram arrived in three sections sent to newspapers. Donald and Bettye Harden solved it within about a week. The decoded text said that the sender would not give his name, despite a separate promise suggesting that solving the code would allow police to catch him. That mismatch between an advertised revelation and the actual plaintext preceded the much longer effort to solve Z340.
The Zodiac 340 cipher was sent to the San Francisco Chronicle in November 1969. Unlike the earlier cryptogram, it combined two obstacles: substitution changed letters into symbols, and transposition rearranged their positions. The decoders' 2024 technical paper describes a homophonic substitution system, in which a letter can have more than one corresponding symbol. Recognizing the substitutions alone was insufficient because a left-to-right sequence did not restore the message. The text had to be recovered through its rearrangement as well as its alphabet.
Blake's firsthand description of the search explains the division of work. He generated candidate rearrangements, which were tested with Van Eycke's AZdecrypt software, while Oranchak evaluated promising results. They examined approximately 650,000 transpositions. One result contained fragments that suggested pursuit and the gas chamber. Those fragments did not immediately supply a clean solution to the entire message. They gave the team a reason to return to a particular rearrangement and investigate it more closely, rather than accepting isolated recognizable words as a complete decryption.
The breakthrough required attention to the grid's structure and to irregularities in the remaining text. The Zodiac 340 cipher occupied 20 rows of 17 symbols. Blake describes a division into sections of nine, nine, and two rows. In the longer sections, a diagonal route moved one position down and two across, wrapping around the grid's edges. The first nine rows became legible before the second section, which contained errors requiring further work. Blake published the substitution key and a reconstruction showing how the rearrangement recovered the connected message.
The decoders' technical paper connects one passage to a specific contemporary event. On October 22, 1969, a caller claiming to be Zodiac had appeared by telephone on Jim Dunbar's television program with attorney Melvin Belli. The recovered text denied that the caller was its sender and rejected fear of the gas chamber. It then claimed that death would bring a comfortable existence in paradise, supported by enslaved victims. These statements establish what the message communicated; neither the denial nor its afterlife claims become verified facts merely because the cryptography works.
The FBI's 2007 history places the original murders under local jurisdiction. Federal specialists supported investigators with handwriting examination, fingerprint work, and cryptanalysis. Their work included attempts to recover latent fingerprints from correspondence and envelopes attributed to the killer. The FBI statement reproduced on Oranchak's research site dates the cryptogram's original submission to its laboratory to November 13, 1969. That statement describes numerous proposed solutions reviewed over the following 51 years without a successful decryption. The eventual solution emerged through collaboration with researchers outside law enforcement.
Oranchak's chronology records another submission of the Zodiac 340 cipher on December 5, 2020: he sent the team's solution to FBI cryptanalysts that morning. The bureau's statement says its specialists independently verified the decryption. Oranchak also describes coordinating the public release with the FBI press office while notifications to victims were completed. He released the team's explanatory video on December 11; the FBI's public announcement followed that day. The bureau then described the criminal investigation as ongoing. Confirmation concerned the recovered text, which contained no personal name for investigators to match to a suspect.
Two shorter messages require their own evaluation. The 13-character cipher sent in April 1970 followed an apparent offer of a name. Craig Bauer's discussion explains that such a short sequence can accommodate multiple proposed names, making uniqueness difficult to establish. The 32-character cipher sent in June 1970 accompanied a map and a claim about a bomb location; a later clue referred to radians and inches. Neither a speculative name fitted to the shorter code nor a proposed map interpretation inherits the validation of the 2020 decryption. They are separate cryptograms with separate evidentiary limits.
- HISTORY, The Zodiac Ciphers: What Cryptologists Know — www.history.com
- David Oranchak, Sam Blake, and Jarl Van Eycke, The Solution of the Zodiac Killer’s 340-Character Cipher, 2024 — arxiv.org
- Sam Blake, The Solution of the Zodiac Killer’s 340-Character Cipher, Wolfram Blog, March 24, 2021 — blog.wolfram.com
- FBI, The Zodiac Killer: View FBI Records on Hunt for Clues, March 2, 2007 — archives.fbi.gov
- David Oranchak, Solution to the 340: decoding chronology and FBI confirmation, Zodiac Killer Ciphers Wiki — zodiackillerciphers.com