A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

H. H. Holmes victim count

Holmes victims: the insurance trail behind the numbers

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Holmes victims: the insurance trail behind the numbers

Nine is the number of Holmes victims that researcher Adam Selzer could confirm, according to Smithsonian Magazine's 2021 report on his research. That finding concerns identifiable people Holmes knew through friendship, romance, or business. It is a different measure from the much larger totals attached to his name. The strongest surviving trail runs through Benjamin Pitezel's life insurance, the disappearance of three Pitezel children, and an investigation that moved between Philadelphia, Toronto, and Indianapolis. Its physical landmarks include a rented house, a borrowed spade, and a body identified for an insurance payment.

The insurance investigation survives under an unexpected name in the Library of Congress's Pinkerton archive. The agency filed the matter as the Pitezel murder, using the victim's name, although the material also concerns Herman Mudgett, better known as Holmes. The library identifies an insurance claim following Pitezel's apparent death in an office fire as the starting point of Pinkerton's involvement. This was a financial transaction with a named beneficiary and a particular dead man. It supplied an investigative route quite different from speculation about anonymous visitors disappearing inside a Chicago building.

The archival collection also has limits. The library describes criminal files containing correspondence, operative reports, photographs, legal documents, and printed material, but warns that newspaper and magazine coverage often dominates them. Only a fraction of Pinkerton's business is represented. An agency file and a newspaper cutting preserved inside it therefore have different origins, even when they sit together. The Pitezel label establishes how the case was organized; the library does not present its catalogue description as a count of Holmes victims.

Holmes was already contesting a substantial tally in his 1895 prison book, Holmes' Own Story. Its title page refers to 22 deaths and disappearances in which he was allegedly implicated. In the preface, he complains that publicity has prejudiced his prospects of a fair trial and says he published despite his counsel's objections. That number records the accusations he chose to address. It cannot be converted into 22 admissions of murder. His stated purpose was personal vindication, and his descriptions of disputed events were part of that effort.

His treatment of Pitezel is especially revealing. Holmes claimed that Pitezel left instructions for making a suicide resemble an accident so the insurance would pay. He described weighing what to do with the body and concealing the death from the family. These are Holmes's assertions, rather than an independent reconstruction of Pitezel's last hours. Even his defense kept returning to insurance, control of information, and the danger of his own identification under different names. The financial deception was central to his explanation of his conduct.

Detective Frank Geyer's 1896 book follows a more tangible route to the missing children. On July 15, 1895, Geyer and Toronto detective Cuddy pursued a rental lead at 16 St. Vincent Street. Neighbor Thomas William Ryves described a man who had borrowed a spade, supposedly to prepare a cellar space for potatoes. Geyer records that Ryves recognized Alice Pitezel's photograph but was initially less certain about Holmes. That uneven recognition matters: the witness did not identify every person with equal confidence. The cellar search led to Alice and Nellie's bodies.

Geyer's chronology places the discovery of Howard Pitezel's remains at Irvington, near Indianapolis, on August 27. It dates the indictment for Benjamin's murder to September 12 and the jury's first-degree murder verdict to November 2. Those were separate events. A grand jury's indictment was a charge, followed by a trial and verdict. The discoveries connect four named Holmes victims to specific places; they do not supply a comprehensive census of everyone who might have died at his hands.

Holmes's conduct at trial left another paper trail. A 2025 Law Library of Congress account describes his decision to conduct his own defense in Philadelphia. He refused the services of the court-appointed attorneys Everett A. Schofield and Joseph R. Fahy, maintained that Pitezel had died by suicide, and later sought his attorneys' assistance. The account identifies Benjamin's murder as the charge for which he was tried and records his conviction and execution on May 7, 1896. These details concern a particular prosecution and the choices made during it. They cannot transform the numerous accusations surrounding Holmes into additional verdicts.

The Chicago building belongs to a different evidentiary strand. Smithsonian's report attributes to Selzer the finding that its lower floors contained shops and long-term rentals, while the proposed third-floor hotel was never finished, furnished, or opened to the public. That removes an assumed setting for mass killings of hotel guests without reducing the documented harm to the Pitezel family. Nine confirmed Holmes victims, a title page listing 22 alleged deaths and disappearances, and one murder conviction describe different things.

The Question

How many victims could researcher Adam Selzer confirm in his investigation of Holmes?

Show the answer

The Answer

Selzer could confirm nine victims. They were people Holmes befriended or romanced before killing them as part of money-making schemes.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.