A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

Are men ever victims of human trafficking?

Human trafficking: an agent's caseload and a man's forced labor in South Carolina

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Human trafficking: an agent's caseload and a man's forced labor in South Carolina

FBI Special Agent Jessica describes human trafficking investigations involving people of all genders, races and ages. In the Bureau's published video transcript, she says a majority of her unit's cases involve female victims, while other cases involve male victims. The scope of that statement is her unit's work. It supplies neither a national percentage nor a count of every person experiencing exploitation. A completed federal prosecution in South Carolina illustrates the male-victim side concretely: a restaurant manager admitted forcing a man with an intellectual disability to work long hours without pay.

Jessica identifies herself as a special agent assigned to the human trafficking unit at FBI headquarters. Her description emphasizes the difficulty of obtaining an initial report from the person being exploited. Victims often do not approach investigators independently. She describes threats to report them for crimes, arrange deportation, take away a child or harm relatives. Some people have lived with the exploitation so long that they do not identify themselves as victims. Local police reports and public tips can consequently supply the first connection between the situation and an investigation.

The South Carolina prosecution had such an outside intervention. According to the Justice Department's sentencing announcement, a concerned resident notified state authorities about abuse at a restaurant in Conway. The victim was removed in October 2014. The FBI investigated with assistance from the Labor Department's Wage and Hour Division. Prosecutors included members of the Civil Rights Division and the U.S. Attorney's Office for South Carolina. That sequence connects a report about an existing workplace to a federal forced-labor case, rather than requiring a disappearance or a dramatic abduction to make the exploitation visible.

Court documents described the victim by the initials JCS. The Justice Department's 2018 guilty-plea announcement states that he had worked at the restaurant since age 12. When Bobby Paul Edwards began managing it in 2009, he increased JCS's duties, stopped paying him and compelled continued work through violence, threats, isolation and intimidation. The hours exceeded 100 a week. The coercive arrangement therefore grew within an established workplace relationship. The description of earlier employment and the later manager's conduct is part of the prosecution's chronology, not an assumption about how every victim enters a trafficking situation.

Edwards pleaded guilty on June 4, 2018, to one count of forced labor. At sentencing on November 6, 2019, U.S. District Judge R. Bryan Harwell imposed a 10-year prison term. The Justice Department tied the conduct to Edwards's admissions during the plea proceedings, covering the period from 2009 to 2014. It described physical and emotional abuse when JCS made a mistake or did not work quickly enough, as well as racial slurs used to demean him. These were admitted acts in a concluded prosecution, rather than allegations presented only at the charging stage.

Federal statutory language helps identify what connected these acts to human trafficking. Section 7102 of Title 22 defines severe forms of trafficking to include obtaining or harboring a person for labor or services through force, fraud or coercion for involuntary servitude, peonage, debt bondage or slavery. Its definition of coercion includes threats of serious harm, physical restraint and abuse or threatened abuse of legal process. The definition refers to a person, without limiting protection to women. Its labor provision also includes recruitment and harboring as well as transportation; the exploitation is not defined solely by movement across a border.

Jessica describes that range in practical terms. Sex trafficking and labor trafficking can overlap, but labor cases also involve compelled work, domestic servitude, withheld pay or withheld passports and other documents. She describes people being isolated in unfamiliar places and fearing that they have nowhere else to go. Her comments about travel are similarly specific: some victims pass through airports, while others work where they were born. When movement occurs, she identifies buses, trains, subways and traffickers' own vehicles among the means. An airport is one possible location, not a necessary setting for the crime. She also describes recruitment through social media and approaches in public places, including malls, areas outside schools and train stations. Kidnapping in a parking lot, she says, is not the principal recruitment method in the cases she describes.

The statute's separate sex-trafficking provision also refers to a person. It covers a commercial sex act induced by force, fraud or coercion, or one involving a person under 18. A commercial sex act is defined by something of value being given to or received by any person for the act. These provisions identify forms of exploitation, with a separate age rule for minors in commercial sex. Jessica's description of both labor and sexual exploitation reflects that wider scope of human trafficking investigations.

The Question

What did Special Agent Jessica report about female and male victims in her unit's cases?

Show the answer

The Answer

Special Agent Jessica says that a majority of her unit's cases involve female victims, but it also has cases involving male victims. Its investigations involve people of all genders, races, and ages.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.