A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

Did Billy the Kid really die in 1881?

Billy the Kid: the body, the inquest and Garrett's stake in the verdict

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

Billy the Kid: the body, the inquest and Garrett's stake in the verdict

Billy the Kid's death left more than Sheriff Pat Garrett's recollection of a dark bedroom. Garrett's published account describes an inquest identifying the dead man as William H. Bonney. The distinction matters because recognition of the body and the sheriff's justification for shooting were separate matters. The first concerned identity; the second concerned whether Garrett had acted lawfully. Both became part of the Fort Sumner death record after the shooting on July 14, 1881.

Garrett's own version appeared in The Authentic Life of Billy, the Kid in 1882. Its final chapter describes a pursuit involving John W. Poe and Thomas K. McKinney. Garrett believed the fugitive remained near Fort Sumner, but his information was uncertain. A correspondent named Brazil failed to appear at an arranged meeting. Poe then went into Fort Sumner and visited M. Rudolph at Sunnyside, without obtaining decisive news. In Garrett's telling, the final encounter followed this uncertainty and an attempt to speak with Peter Maxwell, rather than a successful identification from a distance. His introduction said he had known Billy the Kid personally and had interviewed people close to him after the death. It also said he declined offers of affidavits for publication. His guarantee of accuracy rested on his own authority, a different foundation from the separately recorded jury finding.

Garrett placed himself beside Maxwell's bed around midnight, asking about Bonney's whereabouts. A man entered, speaking Spanish and carrying a revolver and butcher knife. Maxwell identified the visitor, and Garrett fired twice. These bedroom details come from the sheriff's later narrative; they are not a verbatim transcript made during the encounter. Garrett was describing his own actions in a killing whose circumstances had already attracted criticism. His personal proximity to the shooting makes him an essential witness, while also giving him an obvious interest in its interpretation.

His description includes an initial doubt among his companions. Poe and McKinney wondered whether he had shot someone else. Garrett said that neither deputy knew the Kid, while he recognized the fugitive's voice. The deputies' uncertainty arose before the subsequent body examination and inquest. It was not a competing identification by men who knew Bonney well. Garrett then described the men entering the room and examining the body. Their impressions about the gunfire also changed: although they initially thought Bonney had fired, their search located only Garrett's bullet marks, leading them to conclude otherwise. Garrett added that the revolver contained five cartridges and an old-looking spent shell beneath the hammer. He said carrying a revolver in that condition could be a safety precaution, so the shell alone did not establish a shot during the encounter.

The following morning, according to Garrett, alcalde Alejandro Segura held the inquest, with M. Rudolph serving as jury foreman. The verdict named William H. Bonney as the person who had died from a gunshot inflicted by Garrett. It also characterized the shooting as an act performed in the sheriff's official duty and as justifiable homicide. Garrett dated the burial at the military cemetery to July 15, 1881. The named deceased, named shooter and formal finding give the aftermath a documentary structure beyond the sheriff's description of recognizing a voice in darkness.

The circumstances that made the inquest necessary followed a dramatic escape. Garrett described being away from Lincoln when Bonney killed his guards and broke out on April 28, 1881. He acknowledged inadequate precautions and criticized the handling of the prisoner. His narrative then followed the fugitive moving among settlements and livestock camps near Fort Sumner. That background places the final encounter inside an unfinished arrest and execution process. It also shows Garrett defending earlier decisions as well as the shooting itself, giving readers another reason to keep his factual descriptions and his judgments distinct.

The later summary in Wikipedia describes a six-person coroner's jury examining the body and the location and interviewing Maxwell and Garrett. Its account says the jury certified the body as Bonney's. The examination was therefore collective, with a named deceased and an official finding, rather than recognition left solely to the man who fired. The jury's acceptance of Garrett's justification remains a separate conclusion from its identification of the body. Agreement about who died does not require treating every detail of the sheriff's account as beyond question.

The Library of Congress identifies another layer between the event and Garrett's printed book: his friend, journalist Ashmun Upson, ghostwrote it. Historians have criticized its bias. Garrett's introduction openly declared a purpose of countering newspaper reports and cheap novels, including deeds he said had been attributed to Bonney in places he had never visited. He also promised to acknowledge virtues alongside crimes. Those declared aims belong to a participant's effort to shape Billy the Kid's reputation, alongside the territorial government's record of the death itself.

The Question

Later survival stories place Billy the Kid under other names after 1881. What did the identifications made after the Fort Sumner shooting establish?

Show the answer

The Answer

The next day, several different people viewed the body and positively identified it as Billy the Kid. Those identifications led most historians to conclude that Pat Garrett killed him.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.