Bataar fossil case: the dinosaur at the center of a federal prosecution
The Bataar fossil case began with an auctioned dinosaur skeleton and developed into a federal criminal prosecution. A nearly complete Tyrannosaurus bataar had attracted a price above $1 million in New York, while Mongolia asserted that the fossil belonged to its government. The dispute produced a civil forfeiture action against the skeleton and criminal proceedings against fossil dealer Eric Prokopi. The skeleton was formally returned to Mongolia on May 6, 2013, after a federal forfeiture judgment.
The dinosaur's documented history extended far beyond the auction room. The June 2012 civil complaint described an animal from the late Cretaceous period, approximately 70 million years ago. The species had first been discovered during a joint Soviet-Mongolian expedition to the Gobi Desert in 1946. Prosecutors cited Mongolian laws, enacted beginning in 1924, that declared dinosaur fossils government property and criminalized their export. Prosecutors presented those laws as the basis of Mongolia's ownership claim to the fossil.
Heritage Auctions offered the skeleton in New York despite a temporary restraining order obtained by Mongolia from a Texas judge. The auction continued, but its result was expressly contingent on the outcome of court proceedings brought on Mongolia's behalf. The federal government announced its civil forfeiture complaint on June 18, 2012. That filing sought possession of the nearly complete skeleton for its return to Mongolia. At that stage, the government was advancing allegations in a civil proceeding concerning property; a criminal conviction of Prokopi had not occurred.
Scientific examination became part of the Bataar fossil case. Paleontologists inspected the skeleton on June 5, 2012, at the Mongolian president's request. They concluded that it had been unearthed in the western Gobi Desert in Mongolia between 1995 and 2005. Additional paleontological reports accompanied an amended complaint filed on September 24. The U.S. Attorney's Office reported that the bones' particular coloring further supported the Mongolian origin. The investigation thus included specialists' findings about the fossil itself as well as the documents accompanying its importation.
Federal agents arrested Prokopi at his Gainesville, Florida, home on October 17, 2012. Prosecutors announced a criminal complaint involving the Bataar, a Saurolophus skeleton from Mongolia, and a Microraptor skeleton from China. Prokopi operated a fossil business from his home and described himself as a commercial paleontologist. The complaint charged conspiracy to smuggle illegal goods, possess stolen property, and make false statements, alongside smuggling and stolen-property charges. Those were the allegations announced at arrest, distinct from the counts to which he subsequently entered a guilty plea.
On December 27, 2012, Prokopi pleaded guilty before U.S. Magistrate Judge Ronald Ellis. The Information contained three counts: conspiracy concerning the Chinese flying dinosaur, entry of goods by means of false statements concerning the Mongolian dinosaurs, and interstate and foreign transportation of goods converted and taken by fraud. The statutory maximums announced for those counts were 5 years, 2 years, and 10 years, respectively.
The agreement extended the Bataar fossil case beyond the skeleton offered at auction. Prokopi consented to its forfeiture and agreed to surrender a second nearly complete Bataar, a Saurolophus, and an Oviraptor. He also surrendered his interest in a third Bataar located in Great Britain. The plea announcement identified those fossils as Mongolian and described a Chinese flying dinosaur that had already been administratively forfeited. The Saurolophus was a duckbilled, plant-eating dinosaur, while the Oviraptor had a parrot-like skull. Both lived during the late Cretaceous period. The forfeiture agreement also encompassed other Mongolian fossil parts he had brought into the United States between 2010 and 2012.
U.S. District Judge P. Kevin Castel entered the original Bataar forfeiture judgment on February 14, 2013. The judgment forfeited the skeleton to the United States for return to Mongolia. The May 6 repatriation followed that legal transfer. The U.S. Attorney's Office assigned the civil litigation to its Asset Forfeiture Unit and the criminal prosecution to its Complex Frauds Unit. Homeland Security Investigations conducted the investigation.
Further recoveries followed. On July 10, 2014, prosecutors announced the return of fossils from more than 18 additional dinosaur skeletons. They included two more Bataars, Oviraptors, Gallimimus specimens, a Protoceratops, and material from an Ankylosaurus. The returned material also included a composite display of dinosaur egg fossils, partial skeletons, and unidentified prehistoric lizards and turtles. Some fossils had been recovered through civil forfeiture, while others were voluntarily surrendered for return. The U.S. Attorney's Office also reported that Prokopi received a three-month prison sentence from Judge Alvin Hellerstein in 2014.
- U.S. Attorney, Southern District of New York, return of the Tyrannosaurus bataar skeleton, May 6, 2013 — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Attorney, Southern District of New York, civil forfeiture action for the Bataar skeleton, June 18, 2012 — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Attorney, Southern District of New York, charges against Eric Prokopi, October 17, 2012 — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Attorney, Southern District of New York, Eric Prokopi guilty plea and forfeiture agreement, December 27, 2012 — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Attorney, Southern District of New York, return of fossils from over 18 dinosaur skeletons, July 10, 2014 — www.justice.gov