A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

The glittering discovery that drew a government investigator

The diamond fraud of 1872 and the survey beyond the railway

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · True Crime Stumper

The diamond fraud of 1872 and the survey beyond the railway

The diamond fraud of 1872 drew wealthy financiers, a celebrated jeweler, and an experienced mining engineer into a supposed discovery of extraordinary mineral wealth. The assessment that overturned their confidence came from Clarence King, a geologist leading a federal survey of the American West. His party's examination of the ground contradicted the commercial claims surrounding it. The precious stones existed, but the advertised natural deposit did not.

The promotion began with Philip Arnold and John Slack, cousins from Kentucky. The Wyoming State Historical Society's history records that they approached San Francisco businessman George D. Roberts with a bag of rough diamonds in late 1870. Roberts brought the discovery to the attention of banker William C. Ralston and mining promoter Asbury Harpending. Harpending was seeking investors in England for another mining venture when the news reached him. He returned to San Francisco in May 1871, joining men already eager to investigate the reported riches.

Harpending's recollections appeared in 1913, edited by James H. Wilkins, with a preface explicitly defending his reputation. He acknowledged that the earliest transactions had occurred during his absence and that his knowledge of them was hearsay. His account dated the incorporation papers of the San Francisco and New York Mining and Commercial Company to July 30, 1872. Janin's favorable report became public while the location remained undisclosed. The diamond fraud had acquired a corporate organization, with directors and a published expert assessment behind its claims.

King's authority came from a different undertaking. George Otis Smith, a later director of the U.S. Geological Survey, described its origins in A Century of Science in America. Congress authorized the Geological Exploration of the Fortieth Parallel in 1867, placing King under the Army's chief of engineers. Fieldwork began that summer at the western end of a broad geological cross section. The survey eventually extended from the eastern front of the Sierra Nevada to Cheyenne, within a belt approximately 100 miles wide. Its program combined mineral-resource studies with systematic mapping, and its reports appeared between 1870 and 1880.

King had also participated in the California Geological Survey. In the 1874 preface to Mountaineering in the Sierra Nevada, he credited senior colleagues Brewer and Hoffmann with years of sustained exploration. He described his own mountain excursions as a comparatively small contribution to their work. The dedication named survey leader Josiah Dwight Whitney and his staff. King described the California survey's work as establishing the range's form and physical conditions. In the preface, he recalled exploration with notebooks and the accumulated observations of mountain journeys.

The commercial investigation had produced a favorable result. Mining engineer Henry Janin inspected the supposed gem field in June 1872 and endorsed it. Charles Lewis Tiffany had already appraised a sample of the stones in New York. As Smithsonian's history explains, the discovery attracted men with substantial professional reputations. Janin received a fee and an opportunity to purchase company shares; his subsequent sale of those shares produced a profit. King and his colleagues entered the affair after Janin encountered members of their survey aboard a train in October 1872.

The Smithsonian history incorporates the field notes of geologist Samuel F. Emmons, who accompanied King. Those notes record an initial excitement about finding gems, followed by observations inconsistent with a natural deposit. The stones appeared in disturbed ground, while comparable undisturbed places lacked them. An excavation below the surface yielded no diamonds. King led the party whose examination identified those discrepancies. The investigation of the diamond fraud thus turned on the physical setting of the specimens, beyond the earlier appraisals of stones carried to distant offices.

Harpending recalled a final meeting of the mining company's trustees on November 27, 1872. Their public report accepted that the ground had been artificially supplied with gemstones, suspended business, and directed the attorneys to wind up the company. Appended statements included King's findings and Janin's acknowledgment of his earlier error. The commercial venture ended with its own investigators withdrawing the confidence on which it had depended.

The later legal history of the diamond fraud had a different outcome from the field investigation. The Wyoming State Historical Society records that Arnold and Slack were indicted in California for fraud but were never brought to trial. Arnold settled a civil action brought by investors and eventually became a banker in Elizabethtown, Kentucky. The exposure therefore did not produce a criminal trial establishing their guilt. King subsequently became the first director of the U.S. Geological Survey in 1879, following the earlier federal exploration during which his party had examined the supposed diamond field.

The Question

Which geologist led the investigation that exposed the 1872 diamond fraud?

Show the answer

The Answer

Clarence King led the government survey party that examined the supposed gem field. Its findings of disturbed ground and absent subsurface diamonds exposed the deposit as fraudulent.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.