A Think Again Media Group publication
True Crime Stumper

A Boston crime boss and the FBI

Whitey Bulger: informant records, criminal verdicts, and federal failures

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · True Crime Stumper

Whitey Bulger: informant records, criminal verdicts, and federal failures

Whitey Bulger supplied information to federal agents while participating in the criminal enterprise that later brought him two consecutive life sentences. His Winter Hill Gang operated from South Boston, extending its influence across the city and surrounding communities during the 1970s and 1980s. Its activities included extortion of business owners and bookmakers, loansharking, drug trafficking, and firearms offenses. The FBI relationship continued alongside that criminal business, even though Bulger's defense later disputed the informant label.

According to the Justice Department inspector general's 2022 review, agent John Connolly opened Bulger as a confidential informant around September 1975, seeking information about rival gang members. That date identifies Connolly's formal relationship with him. The First Circuit's earlier McIntyre decision traces Bulger's recruitment to 1971 and describes informant activity that opened and closed over time. Connolly handled both Bulger and Stephen Flemmi during most of their informant service, beginning in 1975. When Connolly retired in 1990, the FBI immediately closed both men as informants.

The McIntyre decision explains the institutional incentive. Boston's branch of La Cosa Nostra was a leading FBI organized-crime target. Bulger and Stephen Flemmi belonged to the competing Winter Hill Gang but associated with Mafia figures and supplied information about organized crime. The court described Connolly as the intermediary who largely controlled other agents' access to them. Investigators retained the pair despite suspicions involving serious violence.

The consequences became concrete in John McIntyre's death. After an 18-day bench trial, a federal judge found that Connolly had disclosed McIntyre's cooperation, leading to his murder by Bulger, Flemmi, and their associates. The judge awarded McIntyre's estate approximately $3.1 million under the Federal Tort Claims Act. In 2008, the First Circuit affirmed the judgment and rejected the government's argument that Connolly's disclosure fell outside his employment. That civil liability determination concerned the government's responsibility for its agent's conduct; it preceded Whitey Bulger's own murder-related racketeering verdict.

At Bulger's criminal trial, cooperating gang members supplied testimony about corruption. The 2016 appellate opinion attributes to Flemmi and John Martorano descriptions of Connolly warning Bulger about investigations and receiving gifts and cash. It reports testimony placing the payments above $230,000. Flemmi's cooperation agreement spared him exposure to the death penalty in Oklahoma and Florida and placed him in a segregated unit for government witnesses. Martorano received a 14-year sentence in exchange for cooperating against Bulger and Flemmi and was released in 2007. Bulger's lawyers attacked those witnesses' credibility and incentives. They also argued that he had paid officials for information rather than served as their informant. Bulger did not testify.

The escape warning also reached the trial through a named witness. According to the appellate opinion's summary of Kevin Weeks's testimony, Connolly told Weeks in 1994 that indictments against Bulger and Flemmi were imminent. Weeks passed the warning along. Bulger fled, while Flemmi remained and was arrested in January 1995. Whitey Bulger eventually settled in Santa Monica, California.

The FBI arrested him with Catherine Greig on June 22, 2011. Its announcement explained that a new publicity campaign focused on Greig had generated the tip that brought agents to their Santa Monica residence. Investigators circulated photographs of his companion and information about her habits. The campaign preceded the arrest by days, after a search lasting 16 years. The FBI had offered up to $2 million for Bulger's capture and up to $100,000 for Greig's. Agents arrested the pair without incident. Greig faced a separate federal charge of harboring a fugitive.

On August 12, 2013, a jury convicted Whitey Bulger after a trial lasting approximately two months. The U.S. Attorney's Office described the enterprise's responsibility for 11 murders, alongside extortion, money laundering, drug dealing, and firearms offenses. The victims named in the verdict included John McIntyre, Brian Halloran, Michael Donahue, Deborah Hussey, and Roger Wheeler. Prosecutors had pursued allegations involving more killings than the jury ultimately attributed to him. On November 14, Judge Denise Casper imposed two consecutive life terms plus five years and $19.5 million in restitution.

Whitey Bulger was killed on October 30, 2018, less than 12 hours after reaching USP Hazelton in West Virginia. He was 89 and used a wheelchair. Officials moved him to a facility providing a lower level of medical care despite his serious heart problems. The inspector general's December 2022 review examined the prison system's handling of his transfer and placement in the general population. It identified serious management and staff failures and inadequate policies, while finding no evidence that employees involved in the transfer acted with malicious intent or an improper purpose. The administrative inquiry examined federal custody decisions; a separate criminal investigation concerned the people responsible for his killing.

The Question

Did the Boston crime boss who fled before a racketeering indictment also give information to federal agents?

Show the answer

The Answer

Yes. Whitey Bulger agreed in 1975 to give FBI agent John Connolly information about the local Mafia. He insisted on being called a strategist.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to True Crime Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.